Ducati Monster Forum

Moto Board => Accessories & Mods => Topic started by: diamonddog-2 on April 02, 2021, 08:09:47 AM



Title: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: diamonddog-2 on April 02, 2021, 08:09:47 AM
I looked under search for this answer but didn't see anything.

Will I need a lithium specific battery charger or will my current 1.5 amp trickle charger still work?  I'm usually plugging the battery, on both bikes, into a charger when not in use

I think I know the answer but ......  Sorry if this seems obvious.  Thanks!


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: Howie on April 02, 2021, 09:04:59 AM
If the charger is not one with a desulphating cycle, is a smart charger, not capable of going over 14.6 volts and reasonably young the answer is yes, but since the battery will have a warranty do check with the manufacturer.  Me, I would get a proper charger. 


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: RB on April 02, 2021, 09:09:15 AM
I bought a specific charger after reading about the battery tender specs as that’s what I had using a regular battery.  Chargers are around $30, have had a LI battery on the monster for about 3 years now. I don’t leave it plugged in unless I’m not riding for more than a week. Haven’t had any trouble, but that’s probably a jinx now. Haha


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: koko64 on April 02, 2021, 05:50:29 PM
Tecmate make a great Lithium charger. Make sure you buy a high quality Lithium battery like a Shorai or equivalent quality. Pay the extra $$$ or don't bother imo. Otherwise get premium Yuasa AGM battery. A cheap ass Li battery is asking for trouble.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: diamonddog-2 on April 04, 2021, 08:13:34 AM
Understood.  I was looking at a Bikemaster for around $140 but will look at stepping up to something better


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: rule62 on April 04, 2021, 01:03:02 PM
FWIW... I used a Bikemaster on my Aprilia Dorsoduro and have one now on my Monster. They're good batteries. If you want to step up, go with WPS Featherweight. I've got one I'm my CBR SP and it works well.

I use a Battery Tender Jr. "Switchable" charger. Pigtails on all my bikes and cars. Cost around $35. Just be sure to select the proper mode when charging. 


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: diamonddog-2 on April 05, 2021, 09:40:10 AM
It turns out a Shorai isn't that much more $ than what I was looking at.  Thanks!


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: rule62 on April 05, 2021, 09:54:01 AM
I have heard more negative than positive about Shorai. Particularly about the special connector pins for their specific charger (prone to break or corrode). YMMV.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: koko64 on April 05, 2021, 11:18:22 AM
I have used Shorai batteries in my customers and own bikes for nearly fifteen years. The only issue I had with them was the poor state of charging systems feeding them. I have no deal with Shorai.  I use the Tecmate Optimate Lithium charger on Shorai batteries as I do on other brands.

Shorai batteries have been the only brand I have successfully brought back from the dead. I have seen a Shorai battery withstand a bike fire (gasoline and loom short fire) due to its composite case. The heavily discharged battery was recharged and able to start a very hi comp 944 motor. It's a shop battery ten years later. I have no deal with Shorai.


In comparison I have found SSB Lithium batteries quite fragile in their capacity to bounce back from discharge and have replaced many with AGM batteries.

I have heard and read about cheap Lithium batteries catching fire due to a regulator fault.
My advice is to only use a Lithium battery if you trust your bikes regulator and have quick access to the battery like on older Monsters. I use a Yuasa AGM in my M1100Evo as it has about 22 -23 fasteners to unscrew to access it.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: diamonddog-2 on April 06, 2021, 08:12:55 AM
Thank you all for sharing your experience and information. Much appreciated


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: koko64 on April 06, 2021, 11:38:02 PM
 [thumbsup]
Let us know how you go :)


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: GregP on April 07, 2021, 05:55:45 AM
Just put a Shorai on my Monster. Left the old trickle charger pig tails on when I swapped out old battery with the intention of charging her up the night before a ride. After reading this thread, I’m going to pick up a lithium specific charger.

Question 1. Do you leave the charger/tender on the lithium battery all the time or do you use the method I outlined above?

Question 2. Is this the right tender from TecMate: https://tecmate.com/products/optimatelith0-8/

I left my tender on the old battery all the time and never had a problem until it died. The battery was at least 5 years old if not closer to 10 and I don’t ride the bike as much as I should. That’s not a bad life span for a traditional battery in my experience.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: koko64 on April 07, 2021, 07:37:57 AM
Looks like mine. I may have the similar, but upspec model.  

Get the smartest model they make. I have both versions of that type charger for both Lithium and regular batteries.  I've accumulated chargers for different jobs, among them an old Arlec car charger, a Shorai charger, the two Tecmate chargers and a Ducati Performance charger that plugs into the Evo's loom. The Tecmate chargers are the most sophisticated.

You have the option of leaving it on tender or charging the night before. Leaving it on tender requires a pretty intelligent charger and it has been said that basic brand tenders have killed as many batteries as they have saved. What I like about the tecmate is that it not only trickle charges and tops up, but diagnoses and attempts to save a battery if possible. It also gives programmed pulse charges and occasionally gives the battery "a jolly good Rogering" deep charge when needed.

5 to 10 years is pretty good. [thumbsup]


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: stopintime on April 07, 2021, 07:49:07 AM
The point with a Shorai charger is to charge each cell to its full potential. Generic chargers can't do that. Except on Earth-X (IIRC) which has the balancing function built in.

Unless the world has evolved since I read "all about it".....


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: rule62 on April 07, 2021, 07:59:50 AM
Bikemaster and WPS batteries have built-in balancing function boards incorporated into the battery (as do some others), but a lithium specific charger is still required.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: Howie on April 07, 2021, 08:13:14 AM
The point with a Shorai charger is to charge each cell to its full potential. Generic chargers can't do that. Except on Earth-X (IIRC) which has the balancing function built in.

Unless the world has evolved since I read "all about it".....

You are correct.

For those who ride infrequently, an AGM battery has a self discharge rate of about 20% a month.  An LiFePO4 has a self discharge rate of 3%.  You do want to charge before it gets below 13.4 volts though.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: koko64 on April 07, 2021, 02:55:56 PM
I use my Shorai charger on rare occasion as its functions are limited. The Shorai importer must have a great piece of proprietary equipment that performs diagnostics and recovers batteries as he provides warranty service if replacement is not required.
My sparky mate reckons an intelligent charger like the Tecmate Optimate Lithium can perform most of those tasks.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: koko64 on April 07, 2021, 03:26:13 PM
You are correct.

For those who ride infrequently, an AGM battery has a self discharge rate of about 20% a month.  An LiFePO4 has a self discharge rate of 3%.  You do want to charge before it gets below 13.4 volts though.

13 V batteries in reality I guess.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: diamonddog-2 on April 09, 2021, 01:09:42 PM
After reading what you guys have experienced, I went with the Shorai battery and a tecmate charger.  The charger seems to offer a lot of "smart functions" for not much more $ than a seemingly simpler BikeMate charger.  I had directly emailed BikeMate for some clarification on their charger functions but haven't heard back. Same experience with the seller on ebay.
I suppose any battery or charger will have negative purchase feedback.  My choice isn't dismissive of any one person's opinion or experience. I have found that, usually, if I spend a bit more upfront I'm usually happier in the end, if that makes sense. We're all looking for the elusive "deal" ..... but I hate to buy stuff twice too.


Title: Re: Considering A Lithium Battery
Post by: Düb Lüv on April 21, 2021, 07:12:24 AM
antigravity brand batteries have always raised my brow of interest. lightweight, built in jump start function, and bluetooth battery shut off/kill switch on the car/ bigger batteries. no experience.


SimplePortal 2.1.1