Ducati Monster Forum

Moto Board => Accessories & Mods => Topic started by: koko64 on July 14, 2019, 03:11:12 AM



Title: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 14, 2019, 03:11:12 AM
Anyone know of any tuning house that supplies these? I put an ad in parts wanted. Correct me if I'm wrong, but iirc Dynojet/Powercommander have discontinued selling these as individual parts. I have alternative brands but prefer the DJ/PC version.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: amcjen on July 14, 2019, 06:50:39 AM
I have the kit that contains the PCV and the O2 optimizers that I had planned to put on one of my 696s but decided against it.  It’s new in box, never used. 

I bought it specifically for the 696 but I can’t imagine it won’t work for the 1100 since I think they share the same ECU (with diff mappings I assume)?

If interested, let me know. I was just about to put it up on eBay.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 14, 2019, 01:02:30 PM
Thanks. I already have the PCV and a spare Bazzaz. I was only after the O2 sensors.

The dyno showed the PC O2 sensors gave an AFR of 13.6 in the closed loop section of the map which provided sharp low rpm throttle response and good fuel economy at cruise.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: amcjen on July 14, 2019, 01:26:50 PM
Thanks. I already have the PCV and a spare Bazzaz. I was only after the O2 sensors.

No probs. Would like to sell it all as a package.  Let me know if you change your mind!


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 14, 2019, 01:34:58 PM
 [thumbsup]


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: ducpainter on July 14, 2019, 01:49:07 PM
Tony do you think one from a Hyper, or Multi, would work?


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 14, 2019, 07:16:27 PM
I am confident the Optimizer/s from a Hyper 1100Evo would work as would those from a non Evo M1100 due to both running Seimens ECU's. I tested both two individual single channel units from an M1100 and a dual channel unit that came off that model. The difference is the dual channel is one box with two sets of wires and a fancy sticker. The individual units just sit inline the connectors with no control box so much tidier. Both being PC versions meant that they weren't found out by the ECU or ran too rich clagging the O2 sensors (and triggering a CEL). Im not confident a non Evo Hyper or MTS1100 version would work due to the Marelli ECU.

You know of some laying around? ;D


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: ducpainter on July 15, 2019, 02:38:55 AM
https://www.ebay.com/itm/O2-optimizer-type-3-oxygen-sensor-controller-DUCATI-HYPERMOTARD-S-Dynojet/264183896236?hash=item3d829658ac:g:njIAAOSwmThcW2bh

https://www.ebay.com/itm/O2-optimizer-type-3-oxygen-sensor-controller-DUCATI-MULTISTRADA-S-Dynojet/264183896233?hash=item3d829658a9:g:zg0AAOSwCMRcW2cF

Look kind of pricey, but there you go.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 15, 2019, 02:47:12 AM
Cheers


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: ducpainter on July 15, 2019, 03:31:50 AM
Looks like the same seller in Spain has them. Maybe he'll combine shipping if you can make a deal.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 15, 2019, 04:06:08 AM
I'm pretty sure they're Marelli type Optimizers .
A re flash here from bikeboy is a similar price to a pair of those so I'll keep an eye out. Something will come up.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: ducpainter on July 15, 2019, 04:12:23 AM
I'm pretty sure they're Marelli type Optimizers .
A re flash here from bikeboy is a similar price to a pair of those so I'll keep an eye out. Something will come up.
How do you tell which type they are?


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 15, 2019, 07:14:31 AM
From the bike model although the devices outwardly look the same. Multi 1100DS and Hyper 1100DS ran Marelli while M1100, M1100Evo and HM1100Evo ran the Seimens. I'm working on the assumption they are specific to the type of ECU.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: Dirty Duc on July 18, 2019, 04:41:00 PM
So, these things are full of resistors to mimic the behavior of an O2 sensor?

Is the sensor part number the same across the models? Is the plug?

 My understanding is that the outputs from the various automotive sensors are pretty standard.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 18, 2019, 07:16:57 PM
I hope you're right Q. I don't know for sure and working on an assumption. In also not banking on the connectors being the same but that's easily fixed. Smart moto in Greece had different parts between Evo and non Evo models iirc. I'll go back and check.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on July 18, 2019, 08:07:32 PM
I checked both Smartmoto and PC sites. Powercommander no longer sell the O2 Optimisers in the kits, probably due to the action against them from the EPA a while back. I guess finding vendors with old stock of the Optimisers is the way to go.
I also note that Smartmoto are now only providing their O2 eliminators for non Marelli ECU's at around 40 bucks. It might explain the high price of the Spanish product for Marelli ECU's.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on September 20, 2019, 03:21:11 PM
Anyone know of a US vendor that may have old stock O2 Optimisers?


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: Dirty Duc on September 20, 2019, 09:12:35 PM
Anyone know of a US vendor that may have old stock O2 Optimisers?
My understanding of closed loop fuel injection, though sometimes disputed here, is that O2 sensors are of basically two types. A wideband sensor requires math (and thus a processing unit=chunk of hardware) while a narrow band sensor doesn't. A narrowband sensor seems like the appropriate technology for bikes (that have relatively free restrictions from Euro/American cars).

Seemingly, the only effect of the O2 optimizer is added resistance so the ECU provides a smidge more fuel than the map should ask for. essentially shifting the point in Closed Loop to the left and up.\

Given the curve on both wideband and narrowband sensors, probably your resistor is relatively standard.

Obviously, I don't have one laying around to test, but IME there is little to no variation on relatively stock automotive parts.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: Dirty Duc on September 20, 2019, 09:14:43 PM
Also, a wideband sensor can be told to output a narrowband sensor curve. The narrowband sensor curve is pretty abrupt and non-useful.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on September 21, 2019, 04:01:23 AM
Testing O2 Eliminators at present (made by Smartmoto). Strangely, these are currently more plentiful than O2 Optimisers in todays marketplace. Dynojet and other companies like Smartmoto in Greece and Bazzaz USA are making O2 Eliminators rather than Optimisers. Could it be that the Eliminators are more clearly justified for track use as per the caveat on their packaging rather than an Optimiser that actually interferes with the function of O2 sensors?


Smartmoto claim the Eliminators allow the ECU base map and PCV to take over in open loop form. Testing so far is very positive with surge free response, more precise throttle control and much stronger, smoother acceleration. No CEL, Sensor or plug fouling yet either. We shall see if the devices are detected by the ECU or able to seamlessly integrate into the system.



Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on September 22, 2019, 02:03:31 AM
So far so good. After over an hour of riding no CEL so if it's time it should be ok. Didn't quite cover 100kms so we'll see on a longer ride. Runs better that's for sure.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on September 22, 2019, 04:22:40 AM
Another good effect is that the bike can run a thousand rpm lower in each gear without the previous snatchiness. It's still on the lean side of good AFR, but isn't ridiculously lean anymore as I saw the reserve light come on at 185kms with 3.5 litres to go. Must have been having fun.
 


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on September 27, 2019, 03:21:10 AM
Did over a hundred mile trip through the mountains with Nibor the other day. No CEL light so I think it's all good. I think some dyno time may be needed however.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on November 26, 2019, 08:04:15 PM
Dyno tune completed. Each cylinder mapped.
PCV, WASP Intake kit, O2 eliminators, exhaust valve eliminator, Termi slip ons with DB killers.

100 dynojet hp or 91 Factory Pro hp ;D. 10% variation. I find that funny.
The Monster Evo had a smidge less peak hp and a little more mid range than my Hyper Evo with almost identical mods bar an open Termi 2 into 1 full race system. The Hyper had O2 Optimizers so the Monster is smoother down low with totally open loop.  Otherwise almost identical power and torque. The Hyper had stronger bottom end torque and I'm attributing this to the 2 into 1 exhaust.  WASPWORKS are done, but fear not, you can get a Corse Dynamics or Beast R kit to achieve the same results.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: Howie on November 26, 2019, 09:31:00 PM
Nice [thumbsup]


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on November 27, 2019, 06:13:48 PM
Just a shout out to Dean at Dynoverks in Boronia, Victoria, Australia. Great job and good engagement with my plans, listening and documenting my feedback about how the bike was running, the level of performance work and the kind of tuning characteristics I was looking for.


Title: Re: O2 Optimizers for M1100 with Siemens ECU
Post by: koko64 on December 12, 2019, 03:23:08 AM
Did some back to back tests with another 2013 M1100Evo. This customer bike was stock but for Termis, DP ECU and DP filter kit. I noted crisper and more civilized bottom end response with the customer bike compared to mine. I suspected the Exup valve assisted here, so I also tested the Smartmoto Exup valve deactivation device Vs the stock Exup  operation.

The Exup valve gave more response right off the bottom but created a hesitation in midrange response much like a CV carb. While it smoothed out the torque at low rpm, it created throttle lag when asking for power with larger throttle inputs. Deactivating it gave a much more direct connection between throttle input and response from midrange up to high rpm. This reminded me of the characteristics of flatslide Vs CV carbs. As expected, exhaust noise was also better controlled with the Exup valve in operation.


SimplePortal 2.1.1